A New Church - Why and what would it look like?

 

 A summary of the keynote speech given by      Fr Jan Hulshof SM at the Swanwick 2007 Conference of the Marist Way

       Return
 

Introduction:

  • The Church does not not exist for itself but for the Kingdom of God: to be a
    sign and instrument of communion with God and with the Risen Christ, the
    communion between people, the communion with the whole of creation.
  • The Song of Mary as point of departure: God identifies with a) the humble; b) the
    powerless; c) the hungry.

1. The spiritual struggle in the world of today

1.1 Pride (the desire to appear) vs sincerity

  • Pride is of all times. Pascal: 'We want to lead an imaginary life in the eyes of others.

  • Colin: a) pride especially part of culture of his time: We live in an age of pride'; b) pride of his time is rooted in unbelief; c) to be cured by the example of Mary.

  • Today: 7 am what I appear': a) desire for status symbols; b) incited by mass
    media - virtual reality; c) nurtured by market; d) morbid forms of the desire to
    appear:
    'body made to order'.

 

1.2 Lust for power (desire to be in control) vs communion

  • Lust for power is of all times. John Locke: The world is full of big robbers and
    small robbers, but since the big robbers are in control of power they are rewarded
    whereas the small robbers are punished.
  • Colin: a) arrogance is especially part of the culture of his time: 'Every age has
    had a certain arrogance, and ours has more than its share'. 'Today man is more
    jealous than ever of his independance
    '; b) arrogance and lust for power rooted in
    unbelief; c) to be cured by the example of Mary.
  • Today: a) lust for power as social disease: domestic violance and bullying: 'You
    feel like you are nothing'',
    b) powerlessness of asylum seekers and refugees; c)
    power of share holders; d) domination and exploitation of the earth.

1.3 Greed (desire to have) vs solidarity

  • Greed is of all times (St. Augustine: 'Do you think it's a small matter that you are
    eating someone else's food?"1).
  • Colin: a) greed is especially part of the culture of his time: 'Our age does not like
    the poor
    '; his age is age of materialism; b) greed of his time rooted in unbelief; c)
    to be cured by example of Mary.
  • Today: a) child poverty not only in third world countries, but also in Europe; b)
    greed accepted as something normal ('It is the nature of structural sin to seem
    normal';
    c) link between greediness of the have's and poverty of the have-nots.

2. The Church called to take sides with the humble, the powerless and the hungry

  • Church called to identify with the humble, the powerless and the hungry. But to do so, it needs itself to become a humble Church, less relying on power and wealth.

2.1 Church and pride

« 1 Cor :8: 'Let us keep the feest ...with the unleavened bread of sincerity and truth' ('Sincerus' = without wax?).

  • Desire to appear in the history of the Church (the facade of St. Peter).
  • Colin: priests bent on applause in stead of conversion; close to the elite in stead of
    the poor and/or rural people; religious competing in prestige (schools, reputation).
  • In the life of the Church today:
  • personal life of Christians: external motivations (what do others think of me?)
  • community life: pride that prevents us from asking for forgiveness
  • social life of the Church: honorary posts, titles, decorations and hierarchical precedence
  • moral life of the Church: the link between institutional pride and the abuse problem

2.2 Church and power

  • • Luke 22:24f.: 'The kings of the Gentiles lord it over them... But you are not be like that... the one who rules should be like the one who serves'.

  • Use of (spiritual, political and even military) power in the history of the Church

  •  Colin: Church should not depend on political power and should not bring people to conversion by force (case of Count de Montlosier)

  • In the life of the Church today:

    • personal life: the desire to be in control of things; the difficulty of letting go;
    • community: violence by words, by silence, difficulty of accepting differences, bullying;
    • social life of Church: communion in stead of power (equal roles for laity, for women);
    • moral life of the Church: safety of children and women.

    2.3 Church and greed

    • Matthew 19:24: 'It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for
      a rich man to enter the kingdom of God';
    • Difficulty of the Church over the centuries to live out this part of the Gospel;
    • Colin is upset to hear priests always talking about bishops and money;
    • In the life of the Church today:
          -personal life: many Christians leave Gospel aside when it affects their purse;      -community life: what do parishes, religious communities know about refugees, asylum
          -seekers, homeless, imprisoned, nearby?
          -social and moral life of the Church: evangelical use of property?

    3. Conclusion of the first part:

    'The Society must begin a new Church over again...We too must gather together everyone through the Third Order...' (A Founder Speaks, 120,1). A new Church for the people of today should be a more true and sincere Church, a more communion focused and participatory Church and a Church that in its way of living, thinking and acting expresses a deep concern for the poor and for their earth.

    4. THE MARIAN WAY

    4.1 Two images of Mary: Mary as Mother and Mary as Commander in chief

    • Constitutions of Colin: a) Marists following a loving Mother and b) fighting under
      her banner.
    • The prayer of Cardinal Danneels: 'Holy Mary, teach us to say Yes' and the prayer
      of George Courson:
      'Holy Mary, teach us to say 'No'.

    4.2 Mary and the three No's of Colin

    • no to glory and prestige: 'hidden and unknown';
    • no to lust for power: open to advice different from one's own opinion;
    • no to greed: 'reject entirely greed from the house of the blessed Virgin';
    • three no's apply to every member of Marist family;
    • three no's reflect Utopian dream of Colin, but printed in negative;
    • three no's: important is not the literal sense but that Mary should be in our lives what she was in Colin's life: a bearer of hope, inviting us to answer the needs of our secularized world;
    • three no's are equally against the ennemies inside and outside, but we have to start inside.

    4.3 The Marian face of the Church

    4.3.1 No to the desire to appear: 'Hidden and unknown'

  • « Easily misunderstood: Mayet: 'Yes, it is the hidden life that Father [Colin] extols, but it is LIFE';

  • Test of veracity: ' Work in depth, even when nothing or little is seen, for it is there that the essential is often to be found.'

  • Principle of pastoral: the messenger needs to step back in order to make room for the message;

  • Principle of education: Marguerite Lena in address to Education Forum Rome 2004: like plants hidden in the soil, the process of education follows the law of hidden growth;

  • Principle of ecological care: 'If humanity is to survive it must step off its pedestal and rediscover its proper place within the total network of relationships thqt is our earth community' (Paul Walsh).

    4.3.2 No to lust for power: 'Mary following the will of others rather than her own'

    • easily misunderstood: only the strong are able to abstain from imposing
      themselves;
    • Mary as image of servant Church;
    • Marian Church focused on communion in stead of being occupied with questions
      of power;
    • Abstinence from power as pastoral principle. Colin: We must win souls by
      submitting ourselves to them
      ';
    • Communion of all the faithful more fundamental than distinction hierarchy-laity.
    • Mary as image of Servant Church does not allow questions of hierarchy, prestige
      and power become stumbling stones towards unity (Walsingham);
    • Marian Church is safe place for vulnerable and powerless (cf. Gerald Arbuckle
      about rules for those who assist victims);
    • Education means refraining from power (again comparison with the growing
      process of plant).

    4.3.3 No to greed: 'Mary horrified by the spirit of greed'

    •  In our personal lives: how to live out the spirit of Mary in our consumer society?

    •  What about refugees and homeless (demanding our interest, our time, our resources)?

    • What about supporting initiatives and projects that fight the spirit of consumerism (for instance CAFOD's Livesimply)!

    • No to greed as basic principle of education (temptation to substitute love and
      attention by gadgets, toys, sweets and pocket money).

    5. Marist Way

    5.1 Marist Way Spirituality: contemplative and practical

    5.2 Challenges for the future

    • Clarify more precisely what it means to be a lay Marist, theoretically and practically;

    • in relationship between Marist religious and lay Marists to move from dependence' and 'independence' to ''inter-dependence';

    • In every country promote communication between lay Marists connected either
      with Marist brothers, or Marist sisters, or Missionary Sisters or Marist fathers;

    • On international level promote communication between lay Marists.

    Conclusion

    •  A new Church for today should be a more true and sincere Church, more communion focused and participatory, a Church that in its way of living, thinking and acting expresses a deep concern for the poor and for their earth.

    • This way of living, thinking and acting is the way of Mary, the Marian way.

    • Members of the Marist Way and Marist religious need each other, not just the way they need brotherly relations with any community. Relationships within our Marist family are important in a different way. The way we support each other affects directly the nature or our Marist mission, the work of Mary.

    • This work of Mary is: to be the support of the Church as it comes to birth in these latter days of pride, lust for power and greediness; to gather the people of God. in its diversity represented by the branches of the Marist family. The Marist family is sign of this Marian people and should therefore be open for religious and lay people, men and women, young and old, learned and unskilled, rich and poor, sinners and just. It should focus all its energy on increasing communion.